How to make the right decision regarding your health, and can you really do it?

reasoning using others' decisions to make deci...

Image by Will Lion via Flickr

 

In the unfortunate event of getting sick and having to seek professional care, consumers of healtcare  often have to make a choice between different options for diagnostic interventions or medical treatments. As Gaissmaier and Gigerenzer589 point out, choosing the right option basically boils down to weighing the different statistical risks or chances (probabilities) involved in the treatment options or diagnostic interventions.

In order for a consumer to come to a "right" decision they have to be able to understand and calculate risks (probabilities) correctly. Normally this is not very intensively taught in schools leading to statistical illiteracy or innumeracy, or a life long disability to calculate risks, chances, or probabilities correctly. So the healthcare consumer dependends on the care provider for doing the calculation and weighing of the probabilities for him, thus rendering the concept of shared decision making with equal partners not practical.

As the authors further point out, not even the healthcare providers always get the calculation right.  Be brave and give it a try:


 For those who want to find the correct answer, it is just a straight forward application of Bayes' theorem.

 

 

 

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Language:

Add new comment

Creative Commons License
All content on the site authored by Ulrich Schrader is licensed under a Creative Commons-License. Other licenses may apply for other authors.
Creative Commons explained

User login